…you’ll not want to read this. I am not a fan.
But it has come to my attention that my commanding officer here at the S.S. Herald, in a craven attempt to drive more traffic to his blog, has been writing recently about the show, which he calls a “guilty pleasure.“
Look. I don’t like American Idol, but I don’t care if you do. So the first time Billy wrote about American Idol, I gave him a verbal lashing in the form of a stingingly witty blog comment and let it go.
But this morning, Liggett approached me, head-down and sheepish, to admit that he’d done it again. He’d written about American Idol again, this time because some goofy longhair named David Cook did a “rock” version of the Michael Jackson hit “Billie Jean.” I decided right then that things had gone too far. But what could I do? Billy was beyond gone at this point. An intervention would do little.
The only solution remaining was to, in a craven attempt to increase traffic to my own blog, write about American Idol myself. But this time I would say what needed to be said. I would shout it from the rooftops. So here it goes. Hopefully my sermon on the evils of Simon Cowell and Ryan Seacrest will help absolve Billy see the error of his ways, and maybe even go some distance toward the cleansing of his tainted soul.
As I said earlier, I have no desire to watch American Idol, but that doesn’t mean I’m judging you if you do. I’m not really a fan of pop music in the top 40 sense. It’s just too manufactured. I’m fully aware that I’m in a minority with this position, and that’s fine. Nobody has to like anything.
But when people start using the word “rock” in the same sentence as “American Idol,” well, it kind of burns my butt. Look — if you’re trying to make a career out of rock music, American Idol is the last thing I’d recommend. Not that I know, really, as I don’t have what you’d call a “rock” career, but still. The winners, in my estimation, have been a bunch of weenies and divas who go on to make overly-produced, formulaic records that are the antithesis of rock music.
That is not rock and roll. Rock and roll is smashing your guitar against a wall. Rock and roll is firing a flaming arrow into your guitar in front of thousands of screaming fans. Rock and roll is not covering someone else’s rock version of “Billie Jean.”
I guess you think my definition of rock and roll is damaging your instrument, but that’s not what I mean. I mean that I think of rock and roll as the art of freaking out. The art of spontaneity. Rock and roll is a genre of music, sure, but it’s also something more ethereal that can apply to any kind of art. And that’s why I think it doesn’t have any place on American Idol. The two things kind of necessarily can’t say anything about one another.
And what do Simon Cowell, Randy Jackson and Paula Abdul know about rock music anyway? Okay, I give Jackson some credit for time served in the Blue Oyster Cult and I know he had some involvement with Bruce Springsteen and Journey, but give me a break. Whatever.
Sometimes I think I’m too negative and I realize I’ve probably offended like everyone who reads this thing, but I can’t help it. I mean you no offense, I promise. I also feel all over the place with my anti-American Idol rant. I know I’m arguing against 50 different things at once and all at cross purposes with myself, like a Libertarian in Congress or something, but I saw red. I’m calming down now.
I fully expect Billy to murder me now.